Robin Hood legends / Stories

story · England

Robin Hood and the Curtal Friar

Robin demands a ride across a stream and finds a friar who can answer him with swords, wit and a pack of dogs.

Also found as: The Curtall Fryer · Robin Hood and Friar Tuck. Research reviewed 18 October 2026.

The friar tips Robin from his back into the stream.
The third crossing ends in a soaking.

Read the story

This retelling follows Child’s no. 123, version B, the fuller printed ballad. Its violence towards the dogs is retained in brief, non-graphic form. The different ending of version A is described below. Read the two versions.

After Little John made a splendid shot, Robin declared that he would ride a hundred miles to find his equal. Will Scadlock laughed. A friar at Fountains Abbey could beat them both. Robin swore he would neither eat nor drink until he had seen the man.

He found the friar beside the water, armed with sword and buckler. Robin demanded to be carried across. Without argument the friar took him on his back and waded to the other bank. There he drew his sword and required Robin to carry him back again.

Robin did so, then demanded a third crossing. The friar lifted him once more, walked into the middle of the stream and threw him into the water. Robin reached the bank furious. He shot his arrows, but the friar turned them aside with his buckler. When the arrows were gone, they fought with swords. The ballad gives the contest a magnificent six hours.

At last Robin asked leave to blow three blasts on his horn. The friar agreed, and fifty bowmen came running. Now the friar asked leave to whistle. Robin consented. Fifty powerful dogs answered the call.

Two dogs tore at Robin’s mantle. The animals caught the outlaws’ arrows in their mouths, until Little John intervened and killed ten of them. The friar called for a halt. Robin offered him clothes and a yearly payment if he would leave the abbey and come to the greenwood. The offer ends the story; the ballad does not follow him through a long career in the band.

Versions and variations

Version A: friendship before the slaughter

The damaged Percy manuscript text, Child 123 A, is headed “Robine Hood and Ffryer Tucke”. At its surviving conclusion the friar proposes matching the dogs against the men and himself against Robin. Robin would rather face three dogs than the friar, and asks him to restrain them and be friends. The killing of ten dogs belongs to B’s ending, not this surviving A passage. A and B, especially their conclusions.

Pyle’s four hounds and Allan a Dale

Pyle explicitly makes the opponent Friar Tuck. Four hounds answer him, Robin takes refuge in a tree, and the confrontation ends when identities become clear. Tuck accompanies the men back to Sherwood; the next episode gives him a role in the marriage of Allan a Dale and Ellen. The novelist connects separate adventures into a continuing company. “Robin Hood Seeks the Curtal Friar” and opening of “Robin Hood Compasses a Marriage”.

The name and the monastery

“Curtal” is an old descriptive term whose interpretation has been debated. Child discusses shortened clothing and an alternative derivation. We retain the traditional title without treating one etymology as settled. His notes also distinguish the ballad’s friar from the Tuck of plays and festivities.

Context and evidence

Fountains Abbey was a Cistercian monastery, whereas a friar belongs to a different religious setting. The ballad is not a reliable guide to the organisation of the abbey. Its naming of Fountains does not identify a real resident who fought Robin.

The encounter belongs with the potter and Little John as a tale in which Robin discovers that his reputation does not guarantee victory. Its extravagant duration and arrow-catching dogs are part of that comic escalation.

Sources for this entry

  1. Francis James Child, editor, The English and Scottish Popular Ballads, volume III. Boston, Houghton, Mifflin, 1888. No. 123; headnote; A and B texts and conclusions. distinct manuscript and printed versions, naming and religious setting. Read source · About this book
  2. Howard Pyle, The Merry Adventures of Robin Hood. 1883; Project Gutenberg text. “Robin Hood Seeks the Curtal Friar”; opening of “Robin Hood Compasses a Marriage”. later four-hound episode and continuing role for Tuck. Read source · About this book

Research coverage

The named texts and selected editorial notes have been examined. This entry does not claim to collate every manuscript, broadside, oral performance or modern adaptation.

The Myths · Robin Hood collection · Editorial approach